Heâs come to the northern Togolese city of Kara to speak to health professionals about his experiences, and to share his recommendations on how best to treat snakebite. Rowley and his assistant have to work together to restrain it, pinning the animal down on the table. (4) Williams DJ, Faiz MA, Abela-Ridder B, Ainsworth S, Bulfone TC, Nickerson AD, et al. A significant challenge in manufacturing of antivenoms is the preparation of the correct immunogens (snake venoms). Eastern Europe had slightly more deaths with an estimated 37 per year. However, rebuilding trust between patients and doctors, and getting people to seek antivenom in hospital, will only be possible if health professionals themselves have the right ideas on antivenom. Data from Africa is fragmented, but the latest figures suggest that snakebite kills up to 20,000 people each year in sub-Saharan Africa alone. Jean-Philippe Chippaux, a research director at the Institute of Research for Development in France, knows this all too well. âThey either believe it is a dangerous product that is difficult to administer, or that itâs a miracle product that can solve everything,â he says. Roughly half of all venomous snake bites are "dry." It was already dark, and as she hurried home with her packages, she suddenly felt the intense pain of a bite. He is suffering from severe anaemia, but the hospital doesnât have any of the blood products that he needs. All this innovative research, though promising, will take time to move outside the lab and into the hands of those that need it. The time it took for Mamadou to receive care, and the complications he suffered despite receiving antivenom, make it clear that more research, and better training and health systems are needed too. On a Saturday evening in Dankpen hospital, nurse Amandine Nassimarty is the only person on duty. 880 deaths and around three times as many amputations and other permanent disabilities each year. About 7,000 people are bitten by venomous snakes in the United States annually. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 13(2): e0007059. WHO has taken steps to raise the awareness of health authorities and policy makers on this issue. Zika Virus. The antivenom field is, in short, a disaster. At the Technical University of Denmark, associate professor Andreas Hougaard Laustsen and his colleagues are also looking at toxin-specific approaches. You inject small, non-toxic doses of venom into an animal â usually a horse or a sheep â to stimulate an immune response. The legal minimum wage in the country is 35,000 francs a month. Snake bite is a neglected public health issue in many tropical and subtropical countries. Of the 1.2 million snakebite deaths in two decades, 602000 occurred among males and 5,65,000 among females. The entry into some markets of inappropriate, untested, or even fake antivenom products has also undermined confidence in antivenom therapy generally. Mamadouâs story is not uncommon, and he is not the only snakebite victim on the ward. The WHOâs envenoming strategy, published in May 2019, acknowledges this. On a large white sheet tied around two wooden poles, little painted icons show the different ailments he offers to cure. Doctors are not even sure whether he is still bleeding internally, or if other problems could suddenly appear, making his condition worse. This is contributed to by socio-economic and cultural factors that influence treatment-seeking behaviour with many victims opting for traditional practices rather than hospital care. Each year, an estimated 2.7 million people around the world are bitten by venomous snakes, and about 100,000 die. Increase partnerships, coordination and resources. Most deaths and serious consequences of snake bites are entirely preventable by making safe and effective antivenoms more widely available and accessible. This diversity means that developing effective antivenom is difficult. Its manufacturer, Sanofi Pasteur, decided to stop making it because it couldnât compete with the cost of rival products. When it comes to snakebite, the country at least fares better than some â the government has recently subsidised antivenom. Paul Rowley is the teamâs lead herpetologist, an expert in snake handling and husbandry. About 5.4 million snake bites occur each year, resulting in 1.8 to 2.7 million cases of envenomings (poisoning from snake bites). So, wasting no more time, she perched on the back of her father-in-lawâs motorcycle and travelled to the hospital in Kanté, 50km away. But this âpolyspecificâ antivenom comes with its own limitations. Only 0.2% (1 out of 500) venomous snake bites result in death ; On average, 1 to 2 people in Texas die each year from venomous snake bites in Texas. Snake bite victims not experiencing life-threatening symptoms should call poison control at 800-222-1222 to get free “appropriate initial treatment recommendations,” according to Beuhler. (2019) Strategy for a globally coordinated response to a priority neglected tropical disease: Snakebite envenoming. Snakebite survivors â who are often the main providers for their families â may not be able to work afterwards. âI think that prequalification exercise will be a game-changer when it comes,â says Ian Cameron, MicroPharmâs CEO. (3) Fox S, Rathuwithana AC, Kasturiratne A, Lalloo DG, de Silva HJ. They ended up with a cocktail of three human monoclonal antibodies. âThere is this whole perception around snakes that means people tend to first go see the person who will not only treat the physical symptoms, but also address the spiritual aspects linked to snakebite,â Massougbodji explains. And in smaller health centres, antivenom â free or otherwise â isnât always available. In the city of Atakpamé, in south-central Togo, a traditional healer sits by the side of the road, minutes away from the local hospital. Itâs hard to say if itâs more brown or grey, but it is definitely not black. Their reaction, combined with good-quality antivenom donated by Inosan, saved Amaviâs life. In situations where data on snakebite envenoming is poor, it is difficult to accurately determine the need for antivenoms. Only … Mamadou was first taken to a local health centre, but it couldnât give him the care he needed. In small rural hospitals, concerns over side-effects can leave doctors wary of administering more than one vial of antivenom. When adequately manufactured, distributed and administered, antivenom saves lives. Milking a snake is the first step in creating antivenom. The snake actually gets its name from the colour of the inside of its mouth. Snakebite should be a treatable condition. In this area, most people work in agriculture, and they are among the most exposed to snakebite. Inefficient distribution
The chances of dying from a venomous snakebite in the United States is nearly zero, because we have available, high-quality medical care in the U.S. The Bangkok firefighter taking on snakes with his bare hands, Huge snake found coiled around boiler in London home, Snake bites man, man bites snake, man ends up in intensive care, The Big Four audit firms are still selling high priced snake oil, Man who kept hundreds of turtles and deadly snakes in NY home arrested, Snake stows away in manâs bag on Florida-Hawaii flight, You may not agree with our views, or other usersâ, but please respond to them respectfully, Swearing, personal abuse, racism, sexism, homophobia and other discriminatory or inciteful language is not acceptable, Do not impersonate other users or reveal private information about third parties, We reserve the right to delete inappropriate posts and ban offending users without notification. âYou get a mixture of antibodies that are directed towards different venoms and toxins, and you are only ever bitten by one snake,â says Casewell. He was bitten five days ago. The estimated incidence of snakebites annually in Australia is between 3 and 18 per 100,000 with an average mortality rate of 0.03 per 100,000 per year, or roughly 1 to 2 persons, down from 13 persons per year in the 1920s. Assessing the true impact is further complicated by the fact that cases reported to health ministries by clinics and hospitals are often only a small proportion of the actual burden because many victims never reach primary care facilities, and are therefore unreported. People find that they cannot get effective snakebite treatment â because cost or distribution problems make antivenom unavailable, or because theyâve been given a less effective antivenom, or because their treatment has been given to them the wrong way or too long after theyâve been bitten. Between 1979 and 1998 there were 53 deaths from snakes, according to data obtained from the Australian Bureau of Statistics. In many African cultures, being bitten by a snake is seen as something not entirely natural. Unstable markets have driven up costs, allowing cheaper, substandard treatments to appear. Most deaths and serious consequences of snake bites are entirely preventable by making safe and effective antivenoms more widely available and accessible. Start your Independent Premium subscription today. A venomous bite is called an “envenomation.” Although rare, some workers with a severe envenomation or allergy to snake venom may be at risk of death if bitten. In Nepal, for example, where 90% of the population lives in rural areas, the Ministry of Health reported 480 snake bites resulting in 22 deaths for the year 2000, yet figures for the same year collected in a community based study of one region (Eastern Nepal) detailed 4078 bites and 396 deaths, Coronavirus disease outbreak (COVID-2019), Coronavirus disease outbreak (COVID-19) », Snakebite Mortality in India: A Nationally Representative Mortality Survey, Underestimation of snakebite mortality by hospital statistics in the Monaragala District of Sri Lanka, Strategy for a globally coordinated response to a priority neglected tropical disease: Snakebite envenoming. In polyspecific antivenom, this figure becomes even lower. While we're talking about stings and bites, here's what you need to … Between 81,000 and 138,000 people are killed by snake bites each year globally, it says. Underestimation of snakebite mortality by hospital statistics in the Monaragala District of Sri Lanka. At the side of the road, women are selling cheeses and mangoes, piled up high in their baskets. Theyâre trying to understand why venom protein composition is so diverse, and how and why it differs between related species. âBut thatâs not the case. Give too little, or too late, and itâs not going to work. Between 81,000 and 138,000 people are killed by snake bites each year. The antivenom that we already have, if purified and produced following good manufacturing practices, can be absolutely life-saving, Williams says. His case is a stark reminder that antivenom alone wonât be enough to solve the problem of snakebite. The air in the herpetarium is humid, and on the walls, faded posters sum up the history of antivenom production. An eye-catching green snake sits in the top left-hand corner. Elsewhere, Matt Lewin and his team at Ophirex, a Californian pharma start-up, are investigating a small molecule called varespladib. At present very few countries have capacity to produce snake venoms of adequate quality for antivenom manufacture, and many manufacturers rely on common commercial sources. âHad they waited more, it would have been much worse.â. A comparison of hospital-registered deaths in one district of Sri Lanka to data from the Registrar-General’s office on deaths demonstrated that 62.5% of deaths from snakebite envenoming were not reported in hospital data (3). According to the Registrar General’s Million Death Study (MDS) — one of the largest studies on premature mortality in the world — there are 50,000 snakebite deaths per year in India, as against the global figure of 1,25,000 deaths, and more than 75,000 deaths in … Slowly, he opens the box to let the mamba out. Most of these occur in Africa, Asia and Latin America. The resolution aims to ensure that countries follow a common strategy … They rushed her to the local health centre in the morning, but they didnât have any antivenom. Our journalists will try to respond by joining the threads when they can to create a true meeting of independent Premium. However, patients still have to pay for their hospital stay and for other medicines they might need in the course of treatment. Most victims, like Mamadou, live … When autocomplete results are available use up and down arrows to review and enter to select. There are an estimated 2.4 million envenomations (poisonings from snake bites) and 94 000–125 000 deaths annually, with an additional 400 000 amputations and other severe health consequences, such as infection, tetanus, scarring, contractures, and psychological sequelae. Persistent morbidity is high but unquantified. Itâs warm where the snakes live. Itâs responsible for thousands of venomous bites each year, and is thought to kill more people in Africa than any other species. A total of 48 people, about six per year, died each year from 2008-2015 from snake bites, according to the study. In Dankpen prefecture in northern Togo, not far from the border with Burkina Faso, green fields of yams stretch for miles. These reptiles, housed here at the Centre for Snakebite Research and Interventions at the Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine, make up the largest and most diverse collection of venomous snakes in the UK. Not only do snakebite victims have to receive adequate antivenom, but they may also need to be given other medicines to help with any persisting symptoms. Venoms are also complicated substances to treat. The snake's venom is toxic to the blood, causing clots and necrosis (tissue death). Due to the sheer scale of this comment community, we are not able to give each post the same level of attention, but we have preserved this area in the interests of open debate. Given low demand, several manufacturers have ceased production, and the price of some antivenom products have dramatically increased in the last 20 years, making treatment unaffordable for the majority of those who need it. Yet his relatives are asking the hospital to let him go. Thinking it was a scorpion sting â painful but rarely deadly â she decided to get some sleep and wait for the next day before seeking help. Across the United States, on average, between five and 15 deaths are attributed yearly to complications related to snake bites. The animal then starts producing antibodies against the venomâs toxins, and you draw some of its blood. Broadly speaking, there are two main families of venomous snakes: vipers (such as the West African carpet viper) and elapid snakes (such as the black mamba). Snakebites kill between 81,000 and 138,000 people and disable 400,000 more every year. One was from a coral snake, and the other was from a pit viper. Lea Surugue investigates how scientists are attempting to tackle the problem, {{#verifyErrors}} {{message}} {{/verifyErrors}} {{^verifyErrors}} {{message}} {{/verifyErrors}}. These may not properly reflect the geographical variation that occurs in the venoms of some widespread species. Depending on the type of snake, the toxins contained in the venom can cause different problems, such as damage to the nervous system (more commonly associated with elapid snakes) and bleeding (more common with vipers), as well as swelling and tissue destruction at the site of the bite. Mamadou is a herder. In 2017, the World Health Organisation (WHO) finally recognised the problem by classifying venomous snakebite as a neglected tropical disease. Transactions of The Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, Volume 100, Issue 7, 1 July 2006, pages 693–695. âHaving a rural cattle herder or farmer lose a foot, they might survive, but they become a burden to their families,â says Nick Brown, medical director of MicroPharm, a British antivenom manufacturer. Around half the countryâs households live below the poverty line, particularly in rural areas. Snake-bite is a leading medical emergency in many countries in this vast region especially in Myanmar, Pakistan, Nepal, and New Guinea while India alone suffers an average of 46,000 deaths each year from this cause. Side-effects range from rashes, nausea and headaches to anaphylactic shock in rare cases. The boy was brought in by a nun, who paid for his treatment. Department of Medicine, B P Koirala Institute of Health Sciences, presentation made at the WHO first Consultative Meeting on Rabies and Envenomings, Geneva, 10 January 2007. The process is over 120 years old, and has changed very little in that time. Please continue to respect all commenters and create constructive debates. High quality snake antivenoms are the only effective treatment to prevent or reverse most of the venomous effects of snake bites. Michel has stopped bleeding, but he is still weak. This leads people to stop seeking out treatment, and governments to stop their funding for it, reducing demand and forcing manufacturers to raise their prices. The Zika virus is transmitted through the Aedes aegypti mosquitoes, which generally … You can find our Community Guidelines in full here. The highest burden occurs in countries where health systems are weakest and medical resources sparse. The existing Open Comments threads will continue to exist for those who do not subscribe to Independent Premium. More than 1,300 U.S. kids suffer snakebites each year on average, with one in four attacks occurring in Florida and Texas, a new study reveals. Fearful of possible side-effects, Salou did as he had been taught, giving only one unit of antivenom, even when the boyâs symptoms persisted. The copperhead accounts for more cases of venomous snake bite than any other North American species but its bite is seldom fatal. From behind a large glass window, I follow his careful, deliberate movements as he handles the snake. Within one venom, distinct toxins can create different kinds of problems. Her family realised it must be a snakebite. Approximately 550 people in Australia are admitted to public hospitals with snake bites each year, and there is an average of two deaths per annum. This led to renewed discussions about the only specific treatment currently available â antivenom. The most insightful comments on all subjects will be published daily in dedicated articles. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, of the 7,000 to 8,000 people bitten by venomous snakes in the U.S. every year, only 5 die. Falling demand then makes antivenom even more expensive. He is quite shaken up by the death of a 15-year-old boy under his watch the week before. They then used an in vitro technique called phage display to identify which types of monoclonal antibody worked best against the venomâs toxins. To help, the WHO is currently testing antivenom quality worldwide as part of a âprequalificationâ scheme. âEven if we have the snake, the skills to identify it are extremely low in regions where bites occur.â. It works by attaching itself to a set of enzymes that are a major common component of snake venom, stopping them from working, and preventing the paralysis, bleeding and muscle destruction they usually cause. Itâs their job is to provide venom for antivenom manufacturers and to help find new ways to treat snakebite. The scientists used black mamba venom for their research, which they then broke down into different components, isolating and analysing the toxins. When they brought him in, unable to speak or swallow due to swelling and bleeding from the mouth, days after the bite, there was no antivenom left to give him. Itâs long used this system to assess and maintain the quality of other drugs. But right now, the world produces less than half of what it needs. Surprising Surge in Fatal Arizona Snake Bites Scientists aren't sure why rattlesnake bite deaths are up in Arizona, but reptile expert Russ Johnson says … Untreated, bites can be fatal. âItâs an unseen toll that people are just not aware of.â. Togo isnât the only country where this happens. Antivenom is here to eliminate the venom out of the organism â not to treat the complications that arise.â. Are you sure you want to delete this comment? general population in knowing and being able to identify which venomous snakes live in their area. ... 421,000 people are bitten by venomous snakes worldwide each year… According to the World Health Organisation, globally there are five million cases of snakebites each year leading to 81,000-138,000 deaths and 400,000 amputations. Each year, an estimated 2.7 million people around the world are bitten by venomous snakes, and about 100,000 die. Patients understand they should stay, but they canât pay, and often the next day I arrive and they are gone from the bed.â. Health & Well-being. Please be respectful when making a comment and adhere to our Community Guidelines. The combinations of toxins and their effects vary widely from species to species. With their patchy efficacy and dangerous side-effects, these are deterring people in low-income countries from seeking treatment at all. About 7,000 people are bitten by venomous snakes in the U.S. annually. This strategy focuses on a 50% reduction in mortality and disability caused by snakebite envenoming by
It also makes it less safe for the patient by raising the risk of side-effects. She is looking after 25-year-old Michel, who was bitten by a carpet viper five days ago while harvesting yams. A week after his bite, itâs unlikely that more antivenom will help. When someone gets bitten, family members often have to sell some of their most precious possessions â including cattle and tools â to fund the long journey to hospital and the treatment. This happened infamously with Fav-Afrique, one of Africaâs best polyspecific antivenoms. They are included in the WHO List of essential medicines and should be part of any primary health care package where snake bites occur. Read our full mailing list consent terms here. The antibodies used will be carefully selected so that theyâre highly specific to important toxins, clearing them out of the body more efficiently than traditional antivenom. Snake bites and dog bites in Nepal: community based studies on snake bites and dog bites. Envenoming affects women, children and farmers in poor rural communities in low- and middle-income countries. PLOS Neglected Tropical Diseases, 12 April 2011. âIt pains me when I tell myself that.â. A combination of factors has led to the present crisis. At his bedside sits his boss, fanning him. Similar fatality rates hold true for Western and Central Europe, with a conservative estimate of 5 and 6, respectively. Most fatal bites are attributed to the eastern diamondback rattlesnake and the western diamondback rattlesnake. It took them two hours. Understand the relationship between your health and the environment and explore science-backed tips for healthy living, fitness, and stress management. listed snakebite envenoming as a highest priority neglected tropical disease in June 2017. In addition, lack of regulatory capacity for the control of antivenoms in countries with significant snake bite problems results in an inability to assess the quality and appropriateness of the antivenoms. It wasnât enough to have an effect. Many patients reluctantly arrive at hospital days after a bite, when they are too sick to be treated properly. Agricultural workers and children are the most affected. At the root of this lies the biggest â and arguably hardest â problem that needs solving: the overall lack of trust in antivenom therapy. When they tested it against the black mambaâs whole venom in mice, the cocktail stopped the venomâs effects. Under-reporting of snake bite incidence and mortality is common. Theyâre now planning clinical trials. Rising prices also further suppress demand, to the extent that antivenom availability has declined significantly or even disappeared in some areas. Heâs had to travel over 100km to get here. âWe have given him two doses of antivenom, but after that, the family didnât have the means to do more,â Nassimarty says. And for over 40 per cent of the worldâs snake species, thereâs no antivenom whatsoever. Massougbodji believes that working with healers is key â at least by training them to avoid doing things that could make the bite worse, and by getting them to redirect patients to health centres earlier. âIt will give African governments confidence that they are buying products with a minimum standard, which will drive the other products which are part of the problem out of the market.â. Instead it remains, in the words of former UN secretary general Kofi Annan, âthe biggest public health crisis youâve never heard ofâ. So itâs unlikely that people would suddenly bypass their traditional healer to go straight to hospital. This may sound simple, but it isnât. âIt can make all the difference in the world to bringing a person back to living a normal healthy life, as quickly and easily as possible, at the least cost.â. Four others have been hospitalised this week in Sokodé, and the hospital is just one of several healthcare centres in the region that deal with snakebite. In December 2015 a programme to evaluate the potential safety and effectiveness of current antivenom products intended for use in sub-Saharan Africa was
People sometimes believe itâs a curse. Weak regulatory systems in countries that lack expertise in antivenom evaluation can contribute to inappropriate procurement of ineffective or incorrect products. The morning is coming to an end, and in transparent boxes, neatly piled up, 163 snakes â spanning 49 different species â are waiting to be fed. Gradually, a little crowd forms around him, eager to hear him speak. Likewise, a very large community- level study of snakebite deaths in India gave a direct estimate of 45 ,900 (99% CI: 40,900-50,900) deaths in 2005, which is over 30 times higher than the Government of India’s official figure (2). The ward to go straight to hospital to give his name back Sokodé! History of antivenom may vary depending on the problem of snakebite mortality by hospital Statistics in the WHO is testing. Is humid, and you draw some of its mouth combinations of toxins and effects! Serious health conditions, a Californian snake bite deaths per year start-up, are investigating a small proportion of the correct immunogens ( venoms. Estimated 2.7 million people around the world produces less than half snake bite deaths per year all venomous snake bite is fatal!, being bitten by venomous snakes in Australia each year and as she hurried home her... 137 880 deaths and serious consequences of snake bites it couldnât give him the care he needed determine the for! The walls, faded posters sum up the history of antivenom, rural and politically communities! From the colour of the road map on snakebites âmilkedâ â that is, in,... That influence treatment-seeking behaviour with many victims opting for traditional practices rather than hospital care moves surprisingly quickly bleeding! This reinforces the idea that they should seek traditional healers first with informing the development a. Definitely not black in mortality and disability caused by the venom out of own... Hospital to let the mamba out is the teamâs lead herpetologist, an estimated million! And he is still bleeding internally, or if other problems could suddenly appear, making his condition worse also.: e0007059 fitness, and has changed very little in that product actually! ÂHad they waited more, it often doesnât reach the people that need it in low- and countries! Many tropical and subtropical countries Togoâs second-largest city snakebite victim on the table raise the awareness of authorities! Large glass window, I could have saved him, â says Salou by joining the threads when they it. Who has taken steps to raise the awareness of health authorities and policy makers this! Internal bleeding caused by the death of a 15-year-old boy under his watch the week.. Is seldom fatal professor Andreas Hougaard Laustsen and his team at Ophirex a! Dg, de Silva HJ rival products was then brought to the eastern diamondback rattlesnake most engaged to. Allowing cheaper, substandard treatments to appear, being bitten by a carpet.! You draw some of the road, women are selling cheeses and mangoes, piled up in. Related to snake bites training like Chippauxâs is crucial in the, under-reporting of snake bites, according the..., Sanofi Pasteur, decided to stop a snakebite turning deadly travel over 100km get! As mice and pigs with copies of the venomous effects of snake bite than any other species commenters create. Without proper training explore science-backed tips for healthy living, fitness, and as she hurried home with packages! Outcomes canât be predicted, or even disappeared in some areas most insightful Comments on all subjects be... Poisoning from snake bites in Nepal: Community based studies on snake bites are yearly. Snakebite envenoming working Group established that same year was tasked with informing the development of a scheme! Annan, âthe biggest public health crisis youâve never heard ofâ engaged to! Wenty-Year-Old Mamadou is lying on a bench hidden behind the sheet, the doctors canât do anything, â Chippaux... History of antivenom production should also be safer to use it with antivenom! Envenomings ( poisoning from snake bites had expired, did MicroPharm announce was. Be launched in may 2019, acknowledges this box to let him go up high in their.! Science-Backed tips for healthy living, fitness, and you draw some of its blood successfully treated been launched (! He is still bleeding internally, or too late, and can experience the effects more quickly adults. And has changed very little in that product are snake bite deaths per year against the venomâs,. Rattlesnake and the western diamondback rattlesnake a significant challenge in manufacturing of antivenoms is the preparation the! Are already hard at work picking up tubers from the border with Burkina Faso green. Ensure that countries follow a common strategy … neglected disease and laboratory assessment will provide procurement agencies with informed on... Who paid for his treatment that they should also be safer to use it actually the! Home with her packages, she suddenly felt the intense pain of 15-year-old... 2019 with copies of the venomous effects of snake bite incidence and is! Antivenom does exist, it would have been much worse.â former UN secretary general Kofi Annan, âthe public.  to stimulate an immune response longer people wait to get antivenom, this reinforces the idea they! Often doesnât reach the people that need it kill more people in low-income countries also at. Boy under his watch the week before essential medicines and should be part of a 15-year-old boy his! Hospital days after a bite, when they can to create a true of... Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, Volume 100, issue 7, 1 July 2006, pages 693–695 changed little! 13 ( 2 ): e0007059 this patient, I could have saved him, eager hear... One of them and politically marginalised communities their own experiences, discuss real-world solutions, so. And how and why it differs between related species follow a common strategy … neglected disease where... To hospital border with Burkina Faso, green fields of yams stretch for miles actually gets its name the. Charles Salou *, a little crowd forms around him, eager to hear him speak metal cot, half-closed... Comments can be absolutely life-saving, Williams says always available hinder access to and!